THE AUTHENTICITY OF MUTTAFAQ HADITHS BY IBN KHUZAIMAH AND AL-H?KIM: A REVIEW
Abstract
The muttafaq hadith, apart from ?a??? Bukhari-Muslim, is not widely known, even though there are other Sahih books besides those two. Among the Sahih books are ?a??? Ibn Khuzaimah and Mustadrak al-Hakim. While the authenticity of the muttafaq 'alaih (The hadith of Bukhari-Muslim) is clear and accepted by all Muslims, the same cannot be said for the authenticity of muttafaq hadith outside of Bukhari-Muslim. There is an assumption that the similarity in the chain of narration (sanad) of muttafaq hadith narrated by Imams apart from Bukhari-Muslim does not always indicate the authenticity of the hadith. To test this assumption, this research uses four samples of muttafaq hadith on the topic of "Friday bathing" from Sahih Ibn Khuzaimah and Mustadrak al-Hakim as the primary data. Data analysis reveals that the similarity in the sanad of muttafaq hadith is not an indicator of the authenticity of the sanad, but the similarity in the text (matan) of muttafaq hadith provides an indication of its authenticity. These findings demonstrate that the higher standard of hadith authenticity set by Imam Ibn Khuzaimah compared to Imam al-Hakim does not guarantee that their muttafaq hadith meets the criteria of hadith authenticity. This research provides new insights into the evaluation of the authenticity of muttafaq hadith in hadith studies. [Hadis muttafaq selain ?a??? Bukhari-Muslim, belum begitu dikenal, padahal kitab ?a??? tidak hanya dua itu. Di antara kitab ?a??? adalah ?a??? Ibn Khuzaimah dan Mustadrak ??kim. Jika ke-sa???-an hadis muttafaq alaih (Bukhari-Muslim) sudah jelas dan diterima semua muslim, tidak demikian dengan ke-sa???-an hadis muttafaq selain Bukhari Muslim. Terdapat asumsi bahwa kesamaan dalam sanad hadis muttafaq antar Imam selain Bukhari-Muslim tidak selalu menunjukkan ke-sa???-an hadis. Untuk menguji asumsi tersebut, penelitian ini menggunakan 4 sampel hadis muttafaq dengan topik mandi hari Jumat dari kitab mereka sebagai data utama. Analisis data menunjukkan bahwa kesamaan dalam sanad hadis muttafaq tidak menjadi indikator ke-sa???-an sanad, tetapi kemiripan dalam matan hadis muttafaq memberikan indikasi ke-sa???-an matan. Temuan ini menunjukkan bahwa standar ke-sa???-an hadis Imam Ibn Khuzaimah yang lebih tinggi daripada Imam al-Hakim, tidak mampu memberi kepastian bahwa hadis muttafaq keduanya memenuhi syarat ke-sa???-an sanad dan matan. Hasil penelitian ini memberikan pemahaman baru tentang penilaian ke-sa???-an hadis muttafaq dalam kajian hadis.]
Keywords
Full Text:
PDF (Bahasa Indonesia)References
Abdullah, Emad Hameed. “The Suggestive Connotation In The Noble Prophetic Hadith A Study In Sahih Ibn Khuzaymah.” Journal of Al Imam Al-Adham University College, no. 38 part 2 (2022). https://www.iasj.net/iasj/article/230109.
Abi Hatim, Muhammad bin Hibban bin Ahmad. al-?iqat. Vol. 9. Hindi: Majlis Dairat al-Maarif, 1973.
?bid, Sundus ’?dil J?sim al-’. “Muw?zanah baina Manhaj Ab? D?w?d f? Sunanihi wa Ibn Khuzaimah f? ?a???ih.” Majallah Kulliyyah D?r al-’Ul?m 36, no. 125 (1 Agustus 2019): 533–76. https://doi.org/10.21608/mkda.2019.124565.
Ab? al-Q?sim Al? bin al-?asan bin Hibatullah, Ibn ’As?kir. Taby?n Ka?b al-Muftar? f? M? Nusiba il? al-Im?m Ab? al-?asan al-Asy’ar?. Beirut: D?r al-Kit?b al-’Arab?, tt.
Abu Y?sir, Muhammad bin Ma?ar bin U?m?n. Tadw?n al-Sunnah al-Nabawiyyah: Nasy’atuh wa Ta?awwuruh min al-Qarn al-Awwal il? NIh?yah al-Qarn al-T?si’ al-?ijr?. Riyadh: D?r al-Hijrah, 1996.
Al-Ani, Dr Muhammad bin Abdul Karim bin Abdul Rahman bin Abdul Karim. “‘ZAWAED SAHIH IBN KHUZAYMAH’ ON THE SIX BOOKS IN THE BOOK OF THE ‘IMAMATE’ COLLECTING, STUDYING AND AUTHENTICATING.” Researcher Journal For Islamic Sciences 1, no. 1 (2021). https://www.iasj.net/iasj/article/221160.
Al-Asqal?n?, Ab? al-Fa?l Ahmad bin ’Ali bin Muhamad bin Ahmad bin Hajar. al-Nukat ’al? Kit?b Ibn ?al?? li Ibn al-?ajar. Madinah: ’Im?dah al-Ba?? al-’Ilm? bi al-J?mi’ah al-Isl?miyyah, 1984.
———. Fat? al-B?r?. Beirut: D?r al-Ma’rifah, 1379.
———. Tah??b al-Tah??b. Hindi: D?irah al-Ma’?rif al-Ni??miyyah, 1326.
———. Taqr?b al-Tah??b. Suria: D?r al-Rasy?d, 1986.
Alb?n?, Muhammad al-. ?a??? Sunan Ab? D?w??. Kuwait: Mu’assasah Gharras, 2002.
Al-Bukh?r?, Muhammad bin Ism?’?l Ab? Abdillah. ?a??? al-Bukhar?. Vol. 2. Damaskus: D?r Ibn Ka??r, 1993.
Ali, Khamis Dhari Abd. “The Most Correct Thing in the Chapter in Sahih Ibn Khuzaymah - May God Have Mercy on Him - (a Critical Study).” Journal of the College of Islamic Sciences 17, no. 25–1 (2022). https://www.iasj.net/iasj/article/232061.
Burq?n?, A?mad bin Mu?ammad al-. Su’?l?t al-Burq?n? li al-D?ruqu?n?. Lahore: Kutub Kh?nah al-Jam?l?, 1404.
D?ruqu?n?, ’Al? bin Umar al-. al-’Ilal al-W?ridah f? al-A??d?? al-Nabawiyyah. Riyadh: D?r al-?aybah, 1985.
———. Ilal al-D?ruqu?n?. Riyadh: D?r al-?aybah, 1985.
“D?w?n al-Sunnah.” ttt, tt.
Fauz?n, Abdullah bin ??li? al-. Minhah al-’Allam fi Syar? al-Bul?gh al-Mar?m. ttt: D?r Ibn Jawz?, 1435.
Firdausy, Hilmy. “MENGENAL SAHIH IBN KHUZAYMAH: Sistematika, Metodologi dan [O]Posisinya di Antara Kitab Sahih.” Jurnal Ushuluddin 25, no. 2 (14 Desember 2017): 188–207. https://doi.org/10.24014/jush.v25i2.3507.
Ghawriy, Sayyid Abd Al-Majid al-. al-Muyassar f? ’Ilm al-Jar? wa al-Ta’d?l. Beirut: D?r Ibn Ka??r, 2007.
———. Mu’jam Alf?? al-Jar? wa al-Ta’d?l. Beirut: D?r Ibn Ka??r, 2007.
Hai?am?, Al? bin Ab? Bakr al-. Majma’ al-Zaw?id wa Manba’ al-Faw?id. Kairo: Maktabah al-Quds?, 1994.
Haj, Wael Abdulkarim Mohammed. “Imam Abu Bakr Muhammad Ibn Ishaq Ibn Khuzaymah Al-Nisabouri (311 AH) And Say (the Most Correct Thing in This sectionCritical Study.” Journal of Tikrit University for Humanities 25, no. 11 (2018). https://www.iasj.net/iasj/article/182269.
?ajj?j, Muslim bin. ?a??? Muslim. Vol. 2. 2 vol. Beirut: DKI, 2004.
??kim, Ab? ’Abd Allah al-. al-Mustadrak ’al? al-?a???ain. 5 vol. Beirut: D?r al-Ma’rifah, tt.
?amd?n, ’Abd al-Az?z Sy?kir. al-Im?m Ibn Khuzaimah wa Manhajuh f? Kitabih al-?a???. Beirut: D?r Ibn ?azm, 1996. https://ia600900.us.archive.org/21/items/hadith-01/0474-.zip.
?amd?n, ’??im. “al-A??d?? al-lat? ?akama al-’Ulam?’ ’alaih? bi al-Wa?’i f? Mustadrak al-??kim.” Majallah Kulliyyah Ad?b bi al-W?d al-Jad?d 8, no. 16 (1 Desember 2022): 53–70. https://doi.org/10.21608/mkwn.2022.278160.
?am?d?, Muhammad H?syim. “Al-A??d?? Allat? A’allah? Ibn Khuzaimah F? ?a???ih Kit?b al-Man?sik Anm??aj.” Journal of Islamic Sciences 1, no. 23 (2019). https://www.iasj.net/iasj/article/199717.
?asan?, al-??ri? bin ’Al? al-. Muntaq? alf?? bi Taqr?b ’Ul?m al-?ad?? li al-Huffa?. Damaskus: Maktabah D?r al-Bay?n, 2016.
?, Ibr?him bin Umar al-Biq?’. al-Nukat al-Wafiyyah bim? f? Syar? al-Alfiyyah. ttt: Maktabah al-Rusyd, 2007.
?, Muqbil bin al-H?d? al-Wadda’. al-Muqtar?? f? Ajwibah Ba’d As’ilah al-Mu??al??. 3 ed. Yaman: D?r al-A??r, 2004.
Ibn ?d?, Abu A?mad. al-K?mil f? ?u’af?’ al-Rij?l. Beirut: D?r al-Kutub al-’ilmiyyah, 1997.
Ibn al-’Ir?q?, ?A?mad bin ’Abd al-Ra??m. Tu?fah al-al-Ta???l fi al-Mar?s?l. Riyadh: Maktabah al-Rusyd, tt.
Ibn ?ibb?n, Muhammad. ?a??? Ibn ?ibb?n. Beirut: D?r Ibn ?azm, 2012.
Ibn Khuzaimah, Ab? Bakr Muhammad bin Is?aq. ?a??? Ibn Khuzaimah. 4 vol. Riyadh: D?r al-Mim?n, 2009.
Ibn Man??r, Muhammad bin Mukrim bin ’Al?. Lis?n al-’Arab. 15 vol. Beirut: D?r al-??dir, 1414.
Ibn Mulaqqan, ‘Amr bin ’Al?. Mukhta??r Talkh?? al-?ahab?. Vol. 7. Riyadh: D?r al-’??imah, 1411.
Ibn Mulaqqin, ‘Amr bin ’Al?. al-Muqni’ f? ’Ul?m al-?ad??. Vol. 1. Saudi Arabia: D?r al-Faw?z, 1413.
Ibn ?al??, ??m?n bin Abd al-Ra?m?n. Muqaddimah Ibn ?al??: Ma’rifah Anw?’ ’Ul?m al-?ad??. Beirut: D?r al-Fikr, 1406.
?d, Ibn Daq?q al-’. al-Iqtir?? f? bay?n al-I??il??. Beirut: D?r al-Kutub al-’ilmiyyah, tt.
Irmayanti, Irmayanti. “Metode Ibn Khuzaymah Dan Ibn Hibban Dalam Menentukan Keshahihan Hadis Studi Komparatif Terhadap Kitab Shahih Ibn Khuzaymah Dan Kitab Shahih Ibn Hibban.” Tesis Magister, Institut Ilmu Al-Quran (IIQ) Jakarta, 2015. http://repository.iiq.ac.id//handle/123456789/617.
Jad?’, Abd Allah bin Y?suf al-. Ta?r?r ’Ul?m al-?ad??. Vol. 2. Beirut: Mu’assasah al-Rayy?n, 2003.
J?sim, Syu’aib Hil?l. “M? Infarad Bih Ibn Khuzaimah Min Alf?? Al-Jar? Wa al-Ta’d?l F? ?a???ih (Jam’).” Anbar University Journal of Islamic Sciences 4, no. 15 (2013). https://www.iasj.net/iasj/article/76556.
Kha??r, ’Abd al-Kar?m al-. Sya? Alfiyyah al-’Ir?q?. ttt: tp, tt.
Kh?lid?, Fahd ?il?l Sal?m al-. “Qaul Al-Im?m Ibn Khuzaimah F? ?a???ih (in ?a?? al-Khabr) Dir?sah Naqdiyyah.” Journal of the College of Islamic Sciences 26, no. 2 (2022). https://www.iasj.net/iasj/article/256767.
Mehmood, Sajid, dan Muhammad Riaz Khan Al Azhari. “Im?m Ibn Khuzaymah and His Methodology in ?a??? Ibn Khuzaymah.” Journal of Islamic and Religious Studies 1, no. 1 (30 Juni 2016): 107–20. https://doi.org/10.36476/JIRS.1:1.06.2016.09.
Muhaisen, M. M. Muhammad Hamid. “The Questioning in the Hadith of the Prophet, Sahih Ibn Khuzaymah, as a Model Grammatical Study.” Magazine Aldhakwat Albedh 2, no. 8 (2023). https://www.iasj.net/iasj/article/284787.
Muhammad al-U?aib?, ’A?a. “Mu??ala? (?ad?? Kab?r) ’inda al-A’immah Dirasah Na?ariyyaha Ta?b?qiyyah ’al? Mustadrak al-??kim.” ?awliyat Kul?yah Da’wah bi al-Q?hirah 21, no. 38 (1 Desember 2023): 53–96. https://doi.org/10.21608/bfdc.2023.330402.
Mun?w?, Abd al-Ra’?f al-. al-Yaw?q?t wa al-Durar f? Syar? Nukhbah Ibn ?ajar. Vol. 1. Riyadh: Maktabah al-Rusyd, 1999.
———. Fay? al-Qad?r. Mesir: al-Maktabah al-Tijariyyah al-Kubr?, 1356.
Mu?hi?, al-?usain bin Ma?m?d al-. al-Maf?t?h f? Syar? al-Ma??bih. 6 vol. Kuwait: D?r al-Naw?dir, 2012.
Mz, Zainuddin MZ Zainuddin. “Menimbang Validitas Sahih Ibn Khuzaymah.” Islamica: Jurnal Studi Keislaman 4, no. 1 (2 September 2009): 154–64. https://doi.org/10.15642/islamica.2009.4.1.154-164.
Qah??n?, Sa’?d bin M?ni’ bin Musfir al-. “Al-a??d?ts al-Lat? Tabarra’a Ibn Khuzaymah min ’Ahdatih? aw ’Ahdati Raw?tih? f? Kit?bih al-?a???: Jam’an wa Dir?sah.” Majallah al-Dir?sah al-’Ar?biyyah 47, no. 2 (1 Januari 2023): 891–942. https://doi.org/10.21608/dram.2023.278099.
Sakh?w?, Syams al-D?n al-. Fat? al-Mugh?? Syarh Alfiyyah al-?ad?? li al-’Ir?q?. Vol. 1. Mesir: Maktabah Sunnah, 2003.
Subki, Tajuddin al-. Tabaqat al-Syafi’iyyah al-Kubra. Vol. 1. Halb: Fai?al Is? al-B?b? al-Halab?, 1964.
Suy???, Abd al-Rahm?n al-. al-Ba?r Alladz? Zakhar f? Syar? Alfiyyah al-A??r. Vol. 2. Saudi Arabia: Maktabah al-Ghuraba’ al-A?riyyah, 1442.
Syaib?ni, al-Mub?rak bin Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Muhammad al-. al-Nih?yah f? Ghar?b al-?adi? wa al-A??r. 5 vol. Beirut: al-Maktabah al-’Ilmiyyah, 1979.
Syuhbah, Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Suwailam Abu. al-Was?? f? ’Ul?m wa Mus?al?? al-?ad??. Beirut: D?r al-Fikr al-’Arab?, tt.
?abr?n?, Sulaim?n bin A?mad al-. Mu’jam al-Aws??. Kairo: D?r al-?aramain, 1995.
Ta???n, Mahm?d al-. Tays?r Mu??al?? ?ad??. Jeddah: al-?ar?main, 1985.
’Uwaid, Muhammad. “Bughyat al-B??i? ’an Bay?n Mu??ala? Ghar?b Ghar?b ’inda al-Im?m Ibn Khuzaymah f? Kit?bih al-?a???: D?sah Ta’??l?yah ?ad???yyah.” ?awliyat Kul?yah U??l al-D?n bi al-Q?hirah 32, no. 2 (1 Januari 2019): 885–962. https://doi.org/10.21608/bfarc.2019.108812.
?ahab?, Syams al-D?n al-. al-M?qi?ah. Kuwait: D?r al-Rak?iz li al-Nasyr wa al-Tauz?’, 2018.
———. Siyar a’l?m al-Nubal?’. Vol. 17. ttt: Mu’assasah Ris?lah, 1985.
?am?, Muhammad ?iy?’ al-Ra?man al-A’. al-J?mi’ al-K?mil f? al-?ad?? al-?a??? al-Sy?mil al-Murattab ’al? Abw?b al-Fiqh. Riyadh: D?r al-Sal?m, 2016.
Zarkasy?, Badr al-Din. al-Nukat ’al? Muqaddimah Ibn al-?al?? li al-Zarkasy?. Vol. 1. Riyadh: A?w?’ al-Salaf, 1998.
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
